F.S. 843.01, F.S. 843.02, F.S. 843.08, F.S. 843.23 – Florida Obstruction Offenses

Obstruction offenses in Florida may not make headlines like violent crimes or high-profile thefts, but they can carry significant consequences that disrupt lives and futures.

Here in Broward County, where interactions with law enforcement may be more frequent than in other areas of Florida, due to the area's bustling population and tourism, allegations of obstruction often arise from complex situations that aren’t always clear-cut. But the stakes are high. A conviction can result in steep fines, jail time, and a lasting mark on your record, potentially impacting your employment prospects and reputation. However, every case has its nuances, and with the right legal representation, there are opportunities to challenge these charges and protect your rights.

Our Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorneys can help.

Obstruction charges in Florida are serious offenses that involve interfering with law enforcement officers or public officials in the performance of their duties. These offenses can take many forms, from resisting arrest to impersonating an officer. Under Florida law, obstruction is governed by several statutes, including F.S. 843.01, F.S. 843.02, F.S. 843.08, and F.S. 843.23. Each of these statutes defines specific actions that constitute obstruction and outlines associated penalties.

In this article, we will explore the statutory elements of these offenses, discuss penalties and aggravators, and outline defense strategies that can help mitigate charges or secure acquittals.

Statutory Elements of Florida Obstruction LawsF.S. 843.01: Resisting an Officer with Violence

Under F.S. 843.01, a person commits the offense of resisting an officer with violence if they knowingly and willfully resist, obstruct, or oppose a law enforcement officer, correctional officer, or other authorized official by using violence.

Key elements of this offense include:

1. The individual must have knowingly resisted or opposed an officer.
2. The officer must have been engaged in the lawful execution of a legal duty.
3. The resistance must involve violence or physical force.

This is classified as a third-degree felony in Florida and carries the following penalties:

• Up to 5 years in prison
• Up to 5 years of probation
• A fine of up to $5,000

F.S. 843.02: Resisting an Officer Without Violence

Resisting an officer without violence, governed by F.S. 843.02, involves non-violent actions that hinder or obstruct law enforcement officers in the lawful performance of their duties. Examples include refusing to provide identification, providing false information, or running away from an officer.

This offense is typically charged as a first-degree misdemeanor, punishable by:

• Up to 1 year in jail
• A fine of up to $1,000
• Probation for up to 1 year

It’s worth noting that Florida courts have held that passive resistance, such as refusing to answer questions, does not rise to the level of obstruction/resisting an officer without violence. (In fact, as most Fort Lauderdale criminal defense lawyers will tell you, refusing to answer questions beyond the very basics of identifying yourself is typically wise for those suspected of criminal activity.)

F.S. 843.08: Impersonating a Law Enforcement Officer

Impersonating a law enforcement officer is a more specific obstruction offense under F.S. 843.08. To be convicted, the prosecution must prove that:

1. The defendant falsely pretended to be an officer.
2. The impersonation was done with the intent to mislead, deceive, or gain an advantage.

If no additional criminal acts occur, this offense is a third-degree felony. However, if the impersonation is connected to other crimes, such as fraud or theft, penalties increase substantially. In cases involving felony impersonation, defendants could face:

• Up to 5 years in prison
• A fine of up to $5,000

Aggravating factors, such as using a badge or uniform during impersonation, can elevate charges and increase penalties.

F.S. 843.23: False Impersonation of Specific Professionals

This statute criminalizes the false impersonation of professionals, including firefighters, paramedics, or emergency medical personnel. Under F.S. 843.23, impersonating these individuals with the intent to mislead or commit another offense is treated as a serious crime.

Like impersonating a law enforcement officer, penalties depend on whether additional criminal acts occurred. In most cases, this offense is a third-degree felony, punishable by up to 5 years in prison and fines of up to $5,000.

Similarities and Differences Among Obstruction Offenses

While these obstruction offenses share similarities, they differ in key ways:

• Level of Violence. F.S. 843.01 explicitly involves physical violence, while F.S. 843.02 does not.
• Intent to Deceive. Offenses under F.S. 843.08 and F.S. 843.23 require an intent to deceive, often in conjunction with impersonation, which sets them apart from other obstruction offenses.
• Associated Crimes. Impersonation charges (F.S. 843.08 and F.S. 843.23) are often linked to additional crimes, such as theft or fraud, leading to compounded penalties.

Additionally, obstruction offenses can be charged alongside other crimes, including assault, theft, or drug-related offenses, depending on the circumstances.

Penalties and Aggravating Factors

Penalties for obstruction offenses vary based on the degree of the offense and the presence of aggravating factors, such as:

• Use of a weapon: Resisting an officer with violence while armed can lead to enhanced charges.
• Harm to Others: If the obstruction results in injury to law enforcement or others, penalties may increase.
• Repetition of Offense: Prior obstruction convictions can result in harsher sentencing.

Defense Strategies for Florida Obstruction Charges

Successfully defending against obstruction charges requires a tailored strategy that considers the specifics of the case. Some potential defense strategies include:

1. Lack of Intent

For charges under statutes like F.S. 843.08 and F.S. 843.23, proving lack of intent to deceive can be a powerful defense. Without evidence of intent, the prosecution’s case may fall apart.

2. Unlawful Arrest or Detention

If the law enforcement officer was acting outside the scope of their legal authority, obstruction charges might be invalid. A skilled defense attorney can argue that the officer was not lawfully performing their duties.

3. No Physical Violence

For charges under F.S. 843.01, demonstrating that the defendant’s actions did not involve violence can lead to reduced charges under F.S. 843.02.

4. Mistaken Identity

In impersonation cases, proving that the defendant did not actively pretend to be an officer or professional can result in acquittal.

5. Violation of Constitutional Rights

Unlawful searches, seizures, or interrogations by law enforcement can violate constitutional rights. Evidence obtained through these means may be suppressed, weakening the prosecution’s case.

Hire an Experienced Broward County Criminal Defense Lawyer

Obstruction charges can carry severe consequences, from jail time and fines to long-term impacts on your record and reputation. Navigating the complexities of Florida’s obstruction laws requires the expertise of a seasoned criminal defense attorney.

An experienced criminal defense lawyer can:

• Review the evidence for weaknesses or inconsistencies
• Challenge procedural errors or constitutional violations
• Negotiate with prosecutors for reduced charges or plea deals
• Advocate for dismissal or acquittal at trial

Hiring a defense attorney early in the process can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case, protecting your rights and minimizing potential penalties.

While these charges may seem straightforward, they involve nuanced legal elements and varying penalties depending on the circumstances.Whether you’re facing allegations of resisting arrest, impersonation, or another form of obstruction, it’s very likely there is more legal complexity to your case than you realize. A Fort Lauderdale criminal defense attorney with experience in obstruction cases can provide the guidance and advocacy you need to navigate the legal system and achieve the best possible outcome.

If you or a loved one has been charged with an obstruction offense, don’t wait. Contact a skilled criminal defense attorney today to discuss your options and build a strong defense.

Contact the Fort Lauderdale Criminal Defense Lawyers at The Law Offices of Richard Ansara by calling (954) 761-4011.

---